Hadith in Comparative Perspective
Explores the Hadith literature as a source for Islamic law, ritual, and doctrine through the lens of Comparative Theology.
Program Description & Outline
Syllabus
Essential Resources
Brown, “Introduction,” in Companion, 1–11.
Orientation Zoom Recording
Overview of Week 1
Abdul-Jabbar, “The Classical Tradition.” Companion, ch. 1, pp. 15–38.
Abdul-Jabbar. “Collections.” Companion, ch. 7, pp. 137–158.
Week 1 Hadith Readings
Week 1 Jewish & Christian Sources
Week 1 Discussion
Week 1 Zoom Recording
Overview of Week 2
Essential: Melchert, “Law.” Companion, ch. 10, pp. 205–221.
Recommended: Katz, Prayer in Islamic Thought and Practice. Chapter 1
Week 2 Hadith Readings
Ibn Rushd. The Distinguished Jurist’s Primer. Vol. 1, Book of Purification.
Week 2 Jewish & Christian Sources
Optional: Berg. “Exegesis.” Companion, ch. 11, pp. 223–239.
Discussion - Law & Ritual
Week 2 Zoom Recording
Overview of Week 3
Hansu, Hüseyin. “Theology.” Companion, ch. 12
Optional: Pakatchi, Ahmad. “Shiʿism.” Companion, ch. 14, pp. 281–294,
Week 3 Hadith Readings
Week 3 Jewish & Christian Sources
Discussion - Theology & Hadith
Week 3 Zoom — Rescheduled for Oct 28
Overview of Week 4
Schimmel, Annemarie. And Muhammad Is His Messenger. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1985. Introduction, ch. 2, and ch. 3. Optional ch. 1 for an overview of the Prophet’s life.
Görke, “Muhammad” in Companion, ch. 4
Week 4 Hadith Readings
Week 4 Jewish & Christian Sources
Discussion - Devotion and Imitation
Week 4 Zoom — Rescheduled for Nov 11
"Western Hadith Studies.” Wiley Concise Companion, ch. 2 on the historical-critical study of hadith.
Chapter on Hadith from my New Introduction to Islam — covers some of the same ground as the above